Skip to content
Why Jekyll Island Still Feels Like Old Coastal Georgia
Jekyll Island has always felt different from the rest of the Georgia coast. Even as the island slowly grows and adds new hotels, shops, and attractions, it still holds onto the calm atmosphere that made so many families fall in love with it decades ago. Unlike larger beach destinations filled with crowds and endless commercial development, Jekyll Island still feels peaceful. It’s the kind of place where bike rides last longer than planned, sunsets stop conversations, and traditions carry through generations. Though for me, Jekyll Island has always been personal.
Growing up, part of my grandparents lived on the north side of the island for a few years, back when there honestly wasn’t much there at all. The island was far quieter than it is today. Most people who visited knew it for a handful of things: the old water park, somehow equally famous for its horse flies; the small group of stores all named after Zac; the mini golf course; bike rentals; and the historic Jekyll Island Inn. Those simple attractions were enough to make the island feel special.
Every Fourth of July, my family would gather near the mini golf course to watch fireworks explode over the water tower. Back then, the island felt almost frozen in time. The roads were quiet, the beaches uncrowded, and evenings carried that warm coastal air that somehow smelled like both saltwater and pine trees. Even now, after years of development, that feeling is still there.
The History Behind Jekyll Island
In 1886, some of America’s wealthiest families – among them the Morgans, Rockefellers, Vanderbilts, and Pulitzers – purchased Jekyll Island and established the Jekyll Island Club, an exclusive private winter retreat. At its peak, members of the club were estimated to control roughly one-sixth of the world’s wealth. They constructed sprawling “cottages” – in reality, grand mansions – throughout what is now the island’s Historic District, many of which still stand and have been carefully preserved.
In November 1910, the island hosted one of the most consequential secret meetings in American financial history. Senator Nelson Aldrich assembled a small group of powerful figures – including banker Frank Vanderlip, Paul Warburg of the Kuhn, Loeb banking firm, and representatives of J.P. Morgan – who traveled to Jekyll Island under assumed names to avoid detection. Over the course of about ten days, they drafted what became the framework for the Federal Reserve System, established by Congress in 1913.
During World War II, the island took on a darker historical footnote. In April 1942, a German U-boat, U-123, surfaced just offshore and torpedoed three Allied tankers within sight of the island. The attack was so close that witnesses on the beach reportedly watched the ships burn. The incident underscored how dangerously close submarine warfare had come to American shores in the early months of the war.
The Jekyll Island Club closed in 1942, partly due to wartime conditions, and the State of Georgia purchased the island in 1947.
That history alone makes Jekyll Island a natural destination for ghost hunting after dark.
Returning to the Island With Katie
In 2019, shortly after Katie and I started dating, I finally got to show her the island that had been part of my childhood memories for so long. We stayed at the historic Jekyll Island Club Resort, specifically in the newer green-colored building connected to the property. Every morning, we would wake up and walk down to the inn’s little breakfast nook before starting our day. It quickly became one of those trips that felt simple in the best possible way.
Most afternoons followed the same routine. We would head over to the mini-golf course, play a round, grab nearby pizza for lunch, and then rent bikes to explore the island. Jekyll Island is one of the best biking destinations on the Georgia coast because the island is relatively flat and connected by miles of paved trails. Riding beneath the giant oak trees covered in Spanish moss feels completely different from biking in most beach towns.
At the time, the island was beginning to noticeably change. New hotels and shopping plazas were starting construction on the east side of the island. Compared to the quiet version I remembered growing up, it almost felt surreal seeing active development happening around areas that once felt untouched. Even with the additions, though, Jekyll Island still moved at its own slower pace.
Why December Is the Most Magical Time to Visit
Out of every season, December might honestly be the best time to visit Jekyll Island. The entire island transforms during the holidays. Lights and decorations stretch across the Historic District, the inns decorate their grounds beautifully, and the famous “Holly Jolly Jekyll” celebration brings themed displays throughout the island. One of the most popular attractions is the island’s “Twelve Days of Christmas” light display, where scenes inspired by the classic holiday song are set up throughout the area. Likewise, they offer horse-drawn carriage rides that depart from the pier by the Inn, taking visitors through the island’s historic district while the driver shares stories and history about the area.
The cooler weather also makes biking and walking far more enjoyable than during the humid Georgia summers. There’s something incredibly cozy about visiting the island during winter. The beaches are quieter, the mornings feel crisp, and the historic buildings somehow look even more beautiful, decorated for Christmas.
Katie and I have returned multiple times since then, often with family, including visits during New Year’s celebrations at the inn. Those trips always end up feeling relaxing in a way that is hard to explain unless you have visited the island yourself.
Staying at the Jekyll Island Club Resort
The Jekyll Island Club Resort remains one of the most iconic places to stay on the island. Originally built as the private clubhouse for the wealthy members of the Jekyll Island Club, the property now operates as a historic luxury resort while still preserving much of its original architecture.
The resort is spread across several connected buildings and cottages throughout the Historic District. Some rooms feel deeply historic, while others are more modernized, while keeping the same southern coastal charm. One of the best parts of staying there is simply walking the property at night. The historic district becomes incredibly quiet after sunset, and the lighting around the buildings gives the entire area an old-world atmosphere that is hard to describe unless you experience it yourself.
Beyond the main club building, the island also now offers several oceanfront resorts, newer hotels, rental homes, and beach cottages. Despite the increase in accommodations, most places on Jekyll Island still maintain a quieter, laid-back atmosphere compared to larger beach destinations nearby. That slower pace is what keeps bringing so many families back year after year.
The Island’s Hidden Glass Orbs
One of Jekyll Island’s more unique traditions happens every January during the annual Island Treasures event. Artists hide handcrafted glass orbs throughout the island for visitors to find. Each orb is uniquely made and acts almost like a treasure hunt across beaches, trails, and parks.
We’ve actually never been lucky enough to find one ourselves, despite looking several times. However, the market at the inn often sells similar handcrafted glass orbs. In 2022, I bought one for my mom for Mother’s Day. She still keeps it displayed in the center of her dining table inside a glass container filled with sand collected from Jekyll Island. It’s a small piece of the island that somehow carries a lot of memories with it.
A Place That Still Feels the Same
Jekyll Island has changed a lot over the years. There are more hotels now, more restaurants, more development, and more visitors discovering the island each year. But somehow, the feeling never really disappeared.
It still feels quiet at night. The bike trails still feel peaceful. The historic district still feels timeless. And even though there technically “isn’t much to do” compared to larger tourist destinations, that’s honestly part of the appeal.
Jekyll Island is not about nonstop entertainment. It’s about slowing down. It’s about peaceful mornings, bike rides under oak trees, quiet beaches in winter, and family traditions that somehow continue long after childhood ends. That’s exactly why we keep going back.
Leave a Reply