How to Choose and Book the Right Accommodation for Any Trip

A Practical Guide to Hotels, Vacation Rentals, Transportation, Amenities, Location, Safety, and Total Cost

Choosing where to stay is one of the most important parts of planning a trip. Your accommodation is more than somewhere to sleep – it can affect your transportation costs, daily schedule, comfort, access to attractions, and overall experience.

The cheapest room is not always the most affordable option once you add rental cars, parking, resort fees, rideshares, meals, and the time spent traveling back and forth. On the other hand, the most expensive hotel is not automatically the best choice either. We try to look at the entire trip before deciding where we should stay.

The first thing we recommend researching is how you will get from the airport, train station, or starting location to the accommodation. Once you understand your transportation options, it becomes much easier to narrow down the best location and type of property.

Start With Transportation

Before looking through hundreds of hotels or vacation rentals, determine how you will get around.

When we fly internationally, especially when we are arriving in an unfamiliar country, we prefer to book a hotel that provides complimentary airport transportation. Having a hotel shuttle pick us up and bring us back to the airport can save money, time, and unnecessary stress.

Airport shuttle vans are generally designed to carry travelers and large suitcases, so you do not have to worry about squeezing everything into a small taxi or rideshare vehicle. This can be especially helpful when traveling as a family or carrying several pieces of luggage.

Before booking, confirm whether the airport shuttle is actually free, how often it operates, which terminals it serves, and whether you must reserve your seat in advance. Some hotel shuttles only operate during certain hours, so a complimentary shuttle will not help if your flight arrives after service ends.

When flying domestically and staying farther away from the airport or main attractions, we often rent a car. A rental car opens up many more accommodation choices because you are no longer limited to places near public transportation or within walking distance of downtown.

Taxis and rideshare services such as Uber can also work well, particularly during shorter city trips. However, you should consider how much luggage you will have, whether you need a car seat, how many people are traveling, and how frequently you will need transportation. Several rides each day can quickly cost more than expected.

Transportation often makes the accommodation decision for us. Once we know whether we will have a rental car, use public transportation, or depend on hotel shuttles and rideshares, we can focus on properties that realistically fit the trip.

Decide Whether to Stay in One Place or Move Around

Your itinerary should also determine whether you stay at one property for the entire trip or book several accommodations.

When we fly to Indiana to visit friends and cannot stay at their house, we normally rent a car and remain at the same hotel for the entire visit. Staying in one location makes the trip easier. We only need to unpack once, and we do not lose time checking out, repacking the car, driving to another property, and waiting for the next room to become available.

For a trip built around visiting several destinations, changing accommodations may make more sense. When we traveled from California to New Mexico, we rented a car and stayed in different locations along the way. The rental car gave us the freedom to move between destinations and book accommodations close to each stop.

Before choosing a multi-hotel itinerary, consider how frequently you are truly willing to pack and relocate. Moving every night may allow you to see more places, but it can also make the trip feel rushed. Staying two or three nights in each destination is often more comfortable than changing accommodations every morning.

Why Hotels Are Usually Our First Choice

Hotels are normally our first choice, particularly when we want predictable service, professional management, and more resources available on the property.

We often look at established brands such as Hilton and Marriott because they generally offer consistent reservation systems, staffed front desks, loyalty programs, and clear service channels if something goes wrong. Larger hotels also receive a steady flow of guests, which usually means they are prepared to handle common travel needs.

A hotel may offer:

• A staffed front desk.
• Housekeeping.
• Luggage storage.
• On-site security or controlled entry.
• A swimming pool.
• A fitness center.
• Laundry facilities.
• Complimentary breakfast.
• Restaurants or room service.
• An airport or attraction shuttle.
• Business services and printing.
• Parking or valet service.
• Cribs or other family-related items.
• Help booking local transportation or attractions.

The amenities depend heavily on the location. A hotel in Orlando, for example, may have a ticket desk where guests can purchase theme-park admission, transportation to nearby parks, information about local attractions, or scheduled shuttle service. A hotel near an airport may focus more on flight information, airport transfers, luggage storage, and early breakfast options.

Complimentary breakfast can noticeably reduce the cost of a trip, especially for a family. Even a simple breakfast saves you from purchasing a full restaurant meal every morning.

Hotels can also be convenient when you are tired and do not want to leave again for dinner. Hotel food is usually more expensive than food outside the property, but sometimes the convenience of sitting down at an on-site restaurant or ordering room service is worth the additional cost.

The disadvantage is that hotels can sometimes feel less personal. You are working with a larger company rather than an individual host, and special requests may be passed between departments or overlooked.

I once contacted a hotel and paid extra because I wanted them to arrange a surprise for Katie. Unfortunately, the hotel never completed it. Experiences like that are disappointing, especially when you chose a hotel partly because you expected professional service.

Hotels can offer more systems and resources, but that does not guarantee that every request will be handled perfectly.

When Airbnb or Vrbo Makes More Sense

Airbnb and Vrbo can be excellent choices when we want a more unusual property, additional space, or an experience that would be difficult to find through a traditional hotel.

Depending on the listing, you may be renting an entire house, apartment, cabin, tiny home, recreational vehicle, castle, guesthouse, private room, or another unique space. Some rentals also include useful equipment that would otherwise cost extra to rent or buy.

During our stay in Deerfield, for example, the property included beach equipment that we were able to use during our trip. Depending on the destination, a rental may provide beach chairs, umbrellas, coolers, bicycles, kayaks, children’s items, board games, outdoor equipment, or other extras.

An entire home can also be valuable for families or groups because it may include several bedrooms, a living room, kitchen, laundry area, and more room to spread out. Preparing meals at the property can help reduce dining costs, and having access to a washer and dryer can make longer trips much easier.

Some of our most memorable accommodation experiences have come from vacation rentals. We once stayed in an old aluminum science-fiction-style RV near the Grand Canyon and watched alien movies during the stay. We have also stayed in a castle and a tiny home. These were not simply places to sleep – they became part of the trip itself.

Vacation rentals may also place you inside residential neighborhoods where people have lived for years. This can give you a different perspective on the destination and sometimes place you closer to local restaurants, downtown streets, beaches, parks, or neighborhoods that do not have many traditional hotels.

However, the quality of the experience often depends on the individual host. Some hosts respond immediately, provide detailed instructions, and share excellent local recommendations. Others may communicate very little or take much longer to answer when there is a problem.

During one of our stays in Deerfield, the door lock was not working. We messaged the host, and while we waited for the problem to be fixed, the host directed us to the restaurant next door. They knew the owner, and the restaurant provided us with free food while we waited. That level of personal service turned an inconvenient problem into a positive memory.

One downside of Airbnb and Vrbo is that guests are often expected to complete checkout tasks before leaving. Depending on the property, you may be asked to take out the trash, wash the dishes, place used towels and bedding in a designated area, start a load of laundry, return furniture to its original position, or follow other cleaning instructions.

These rules are usually listed in the house manual or checkout instructions, but they can sometimes feel excessive – especially when the reservation also includes a large cleaning fee. Before booking, review the house rules and recent guest comments so you understand exactly what will be expected at the end of the stay. A vacation rental may offer more space and amenities, but it can also require more work from the guest than a traditional hotel.

Understand the Uncertainty of Vacation Rentals

Vacation rentals can offer more personality, privacy, and space, but they may also involve more uncertainty than hotels.

With a hotel, there is usually a front desk or central customer-service department. At a private rental, you may be depending on one person to answer the phone, provide access instructions, and arrange repairs.

Before booking, review:

• The number and quality of recent reviews.
• The host’s response history.
• Check-in and checkout instructions.
• Cleaning fees.
• Service fees.
• Cancellation terms.
• Security deposits.
• House rules.
• Parking availability.
• Accessibility.
• Heating and air-conditioning.
• Cameras disclosed on the property.
• Whether the listing is for an entire home or a private room.
• How quickly previous problems were resolved.

Pay attention to patterns in reviews rather than focusing only on one unusually positive or negative experience. If several guests mention cleanliness, noise, difficult check-in, unreliable Wi-Fi, or inaccurate photos, take those comments seriously.

There have been widely shared stories involving security concerns and uncomfortable vacation-rental experiences. These are not representative of every property, but it is still reasonable to be cautious.

Check doors and windows after arriving, understand which areas are private, and review all disclosed security devices before booking. When something feels incorrect or unsafe, contact the booking platform and remove yourself from the situation when necessary.

Check Whether the Rental Is Legal and Authorized

This deserves additional attention during international travel.

Short-term rentals can be restricted by national laws, local regulations, lease agreements, condominium rules, or individual building policies. A property may appear available on a booking platform even when short-term guests are not permitted inside that particular building.

Katie experienced something similar while traveling with her family in South Korea. The stay ultimately went fine, but the rental situation created uncertainty that most travelers would rather avoid.

You do not want to arrive in another country and feel as though you need to hide from building staff, avoid speaking to neighbors, or pretend that you are not a short-term guest.

Before booking an international vacation rental, research the city’s current short-term rental rules. Read the listing carefully, check for a license or registration number when one is required, and ask the host directly whether short-term rentals are authorized in that building.

The laws can change, and legal requirements vary widely. When the situation seems unclear or the host gives evasive answers, booking a hotel may be the more comfortable option.

Compare the Real Total Price

Do not compare accommodations using only the nightly rate.

The actual cost may include:

• Taxes.
• Resort fees.
• Cleaning fees.
• Booking or service fees.
• Parking.
• Valet charges.
• Pet fees.
• Additional guest fees.
• Security deposits.
• Breakfast.
• Laundry.
• Transportation.
• Rental-car costs.
• Tolls.
• Rideshare fares.

A hotel with a higher nightly rate may ultimately cost less if it includes breakfast, parking, airport transportation, and attraction shuttles.

A vacation rental may provide better value for a larger family if it includes several bedrooms, laundry, a kitchen, free parking, and useful equipment. However, a short rental can become expensive when a large cleaning fee is added to only one or two nights.

Calculate the complete stay rather than making a decision based on the first price shown in the search results.

Look Carefully at the Location

A property can look close to an attraction on a map while still being inconvenient to reach.

Check the actual driving, walking, or public-transportation time. A river, highway, mountain, train track, or limited bridge crossing can make a nearby location take much longer to access.

Research the surrounding neighborhood and consider:

• Distance from the airport.
• Access to public transportation.
• Distance to your main attractions.
• Nearby restaurants and grocery stores.
• Parking availability.
• Road conditions.
• Noise.
• Lighting at night.
• Accessibility with luggage.
• Whether the area remains active after dark.

Staying downtown can make it easier to walk to restaurants and attractions, but downtown parking may be expensive. Staying farther away may reduce the room rate, but you may spend more money and time driving each day.

The best location depends on the purpose of the trip.

Consider the View and the Experience

Sometimes the accommodation itself provides the experience you are traveling for.

We once stayed in a hotel during New Year’s and watched the fireworks from the comfort of our room. We did not have to stand in a crowded viewing area, arrange transportation afterward, or worry about finding our way back late at night.

A room with a view may cost more, but it can also replace another paid activity or create one of the most memorable parts of the trip.

When comparing rooms, determine whether terms such as “ocean view,” “partial view,” “city view,” or “fireworks view” are clearly defined. Look at guest photos rather than relying entirely on promotional images.

You may also want to contact the property and ask which rooms provide the view you want. Requests are not always guaranteed, but confirming the correct room category before paying can prevent disappointment.

Review the Food Options

Food access matters more than many travelers initially realize.

Hotels may offer room service, restaurants, convenience stores, breakfast, lounges, or small markets. The prices are often higher, but having food available inside the property can be extremely helpful after a long travel day.

Vacation rentals may have full kitchens and allow you to order delivery through services such as DoorDash, Uber Eats, or a local equivalent. However, delivery availability can be limited in rural locations, gated communities, and international destinations.

Before booking, find out:

• Whether breakfast is included.
• When the restaurants open and close.
• Whether room service is available.
• Whether the room has a refrigerator or microwave.
• Whether a vacation rental has usable cookware.
• How close the nearest grocery store is.
• Whether delivery drivers can access the property.

A beautiful remote cabin may be perfect until you realize the closest open restaurant is an hour away.

Check the Cancellation and Payment Rules

Travel plans can change because of illness, weather, flight cancellations, work, or family emergencies.

Before paying, understand whether the reservation is refundable, partially refundable, or completely nonrefundable. Check the exact cancellation deadline and the time zone used for that deadline.

A cheaper nonrefundable reservation may be worth the risk for a simple trip, but flexible booking can be valuable for an international itinerary arranged months in advance.

Use a reputable booking website or book directly with the hotel or rental platform. Be cautious when someone asks you to move the conversation or payment outside the official system.

Search the property’s name and address before booking. Confirm that the listing appears legitimate and that the price is reasonably consistent with similar accommodations nearby.

Confirm the Details Before You Leave

A few days before the trip, review the entire reservation.

Confirm:

• The property’s name and address.
• Check-in and checkout times.
• Airport shuttle instructions.
• Parking details.
• Total amount due.
• Deposit requirements.
• Identification requirements.
• Front-desk or host contact information.
• After-hours arrival procedures.
• Door codes or key pickup instructions.
• Wi-Fi availability.
• Included amenities.
• Any construction or service closures.
• The cancellation policy.

For an international trip, save the address in both English and the local language when possible. This can make it easier to show the destination to a taxi driver or transportation employee.

Take screenshots of the reservation and access instructions so you can view them without cellular service.

Choosing the Best Accommodation for Your Trip

There is no single type of accommodation that works best for every trip.

Hotels are normally our first choice because they tend to provide more professional systems, security, amenities, and on-site help. Vacation rentals are often our choice when we want an entire home, a unique experience, a kitchen, included equipment, or a location that traditional hotels cannot offer.

Transportation should be one of the first deciding factors. A complimentary airport shuttle can make an international arrival much easier. A rental car can open up less expensive or more interesting properties outside the city center. Public transportation can make a downtown hotel more practical, while frequent rideshare costs can make a seemingly affordable property more expensive.

Think about how you will use the accommodation rather than only how it looks in photographs. Determine whether you need convenience, security, space, a kitchen, a view, family amenities, or a memorable experience.

Research the location, read recent reviews, calculate the full cost, confirm the rules, and save all important information before leaving.

The goal is not to find the universally “best” accommodation. It is to find the option that makes your specific trip easier, safer, more comfortable, and more enjoyable.

Prepare for Unexpected Accommodation Problems

Try not to let the possibility of something going wrong make the planning process stressful, but always leave yourself a backup option. We recommend setting aside at least a few hundred extra dollars for unexpected travel expenses. A reservation may be canceled, a property may not match its listing, transportation may cost more than expected, or you may decide that an accommodation does not feel safe after you arrive. Having emergency funds available gives you the freedom to change plans instead of feeling trapped because you already paid for the original stay.

We experienced this once after renting an Airbnb. When we arrived, the surrounding area felt unsafe, and the available parking was nearly a 20-minute walk away. We would have needed to carry all of our luggage through an unfamiliar neighborhood to reach the property, which was not what we believed we were booking. For our safety, I decided not to stay there. We documented the problem, disputed the reservation, and requested a refund because the listing information did not accurately represent the situation. We then booked a last-minute hotel near the Mall of America, and it ended up being perfect for the trip. Problems can happen even after careful research, but having extra money, taking photos, keeping communication inside the booking platform, and trusting your judgment can make it much easier to move on and enjoy the rest of your vacation.

---

Ready to start planning your own trip? Visit our Book Your Trip page to explore our favorite resources for booking hotels, flights, rental cars, tours, attractions, and more. We’ve organized everything in one place to make planning your next adventure as simple as possible. [Click here to start booking your trip.]